The True "Palestinians"

Where do Jews come from? Antisemites push the narrative that Jews are mere ‘occupiers’ of the land of Israel, pushing out the indigenous ‘Palestinians.’ Though faith is an integral part of the Jewish culture, Jews are not a religion. The working definition of religion means ideas spread across borders and the need to seek converts. Jews do neither. 

There are only three actual religions: Christianity, Islam, and Buddhism. Jews, Assyrians, Druze, Yazidis, and Hindus are races of people with strong faiths, culture, and customs. Jews emerged from the Semitic tribes in Israel and formed a nation 4,000 years ago. From a historical angle, Jews created monotheism and built a culture and society around that concept. From a faith-based angle, Jews accepted monotheism and then created a society to support that then new concept.

The tribes geographically were located in what is now Northern Israel, Southern Israel, in parts of today’s Jordan, and in the Judea & Samaria region of today’s Israel.  This is important to note as the 1920 Mandate of Palestine map of the Jewish homeland included the entire region of Palestine to reflect the Jewish tribes’ provenance. 

Jews of Pekin
A group photo of Jewish villagers in Peki'in. During the 19th and 20th centuries, many Jews were expelled by the Arabs and Ottomans. Due to the mountainaous landscape, many of the Priestly class hid out in this location during Roman times.

Photo source: Click here

All modern genetic Jews trace back to either the Kingdom of Israel (the Assyrian Exile beginning in 722 BC relocated Jews throughout the Assyrian Empire) or the Kingdom of Judah. 

Today, many Persian Jews, Kurdish Jews, Bukharian Jews, Azeri Jews, and even a percentage of the Pashtun tribe in Afghanistan trace back to the Kingdom of Israel. Other genetic Jews can trace their lineage back to the Tribes of Judah (Ashkenaz, Sephardic, and many Mizrahi Jews). The very name ‘Jews’ stems from Judea, but there was no real difference between the Israelites and the Judeans. Just different leadership. In fact, the two names were interchangeable. When the Kingdom of Israel was exiled, the remaining Judean tribes renamed the entire region, ‘Judea.’

The Judean tribes in particular were warriors and fought against the northern Israelite tribes, in addition to outside adversaries.

Enemies were numerous; not only regionally, but also ruthless empires who wished to utilize Israel as a crucial crossroad point into other regions. Jews withstood many who wanted to subjugate them, but one enemy in particular proved to be too mighty to withstand: the Roman Empire. Many falsely believe that the Romans were antisemitic, but they were not. True antisemitism did not emerge until the rise of Christianity.

The Romans punished any group which stood in their way, and the Jews, who cost the Romans more men and money to fight than any other people, were punished viciously. Many Jews were taken as slaves after the Romans destroyed the second Temple in 70 CE. But the Romans were not finished punishing Jews; the final retribution was that after the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 CE, the Romans dealt one ‘final’ or so they thought, blow to Jews and renamed the land of Israel, Syria Palestina after one of the Jews’ most bitter rivals, the Philistines, who were a seafaring people living in today’s Gaza. The Greeks at the time also used the word Palestina to describe Israel.

  • There were no Arabs in Israel at the time, as Arabs lived in the Arabian Peninsula and had not made their way to Israel as of yet. That migration came later as Islam began to spread.

Though Jews remained in Israel and were subjects of the Roman Empire, numerous Jews were now in the Diaspora and it was in the Diaspora that Jews were referred to, for thousands of years, as Palestinians, the people from Palestine. However, many Jewish priestly class members ended up as farmers in the Northern Israel town of Peki’in, while others hid in the mountains and hills of Judea & Samaria. Therefore, there was always a continual presence of Jews in the land of Israel. Not one year saw Israel Jew-free. Jews were living in Israel under every single conqueror: from the Romans to the British.
Ancient map of Palestine
Map of ancient Palestine; printed in 1845

Photo source: ISTOCK photo

Margalit Zinati last living Jew in Pekiiin
Margalit Zinati: last living member of the Zinati family of Peki'in, who were direct descendants of one of the three priestly families who came from the destruction of the Second Temple in Jerusalem to Peki’in.

Photo source: Click here

Jews draining swamps in Israel
Jews draining swamps In Israel; 1920s

Photo source: Click here

Gaza Synagogue
Picture of King David in a 6th century synagogue in Gaza; By the time the Arabs arrived in Gaza in the 7th century CE, Jews had been living in Gaza for over 2,000 years. During Roman times, Gaza was where Jewsih slaves were sold to the Roman Empire. By the 4th century CE, Jews had returned to Gaza and the area had become the center of commerce for Palestine. During the British Mandate, the Brits evacuated Jews from Gaza after the Arab Revolts in other parts of Palestine.

Photo source: Click here

Pekiin Cave
The entrance to the cave where the Rashbi (Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai) hid from the Romans

Photo source: Click here

Jews at the Kotel in 1859
Jews at the Kotel in 1859

Photo source: Click here